soundadvice for musicians

Provided by
Play It Again Sam
www.guitarsam.com

Harmonica Questions
Got questions about your musical instruments? Are you trying to locate, identify, repair, maybe learn to play? We have been answering questions and solving musical problems for years!

If something has you stumped about your musical equipment, or maybe you just need a second opinion, click on the question button below, and we'll give you our best answer, usually within 24 hours!


Good questions to ask :)

About the operation and maintenance of your equipment, history, how to connect things, how to get the best sounds, how to get service, how to find instruction.


Questions to not ask :(

"How much is my stuff worth?", "Will you buy my stuff?", "How much should I pay for a pink Tele?".


Note: We can help you with a generalized value of your equipment, but without seeing it, we cannot quote you an accurate appraisal. Any assistance we offer you in terms of buying and selling musical equipment is to be considered "averaged information" and not to be specific about your piece of equipment.


View Harmonica Questions below!

Click this button to send us your questions!

Harmonica Q+A

Click on any topic to view the full question and answer!

Rod Piazza "Mighty Flyer" Harp amp
Sticky notes on the harmonica...
Harmonica has become hard to play...
Harmonicas with slide lever...
Cleaning a harmonica..
Getting the "Little Walter" sound..
How to make harmonica heard above band..
Best key to get when beginning?
Is the harmonica an easy instrument to learn?
How do I bend notes?
 


 

Q. My husband is REALLY into the blues and has played for over 20 years. I've tried to find out some information on the Rod Piazza "Mighty Flyer" Harp amp with NO luck! Have you ever hear of one? Does it really exist? I have spent hours looking on the net and can't find a single reference for this amp.

A. Rod Piazza's amp is a custom-made tube amplifier with six 10" speakers. It is big, loud, and very expensive, i.e. in the neighborhood of $1,500.00. I would only recommend such an amp to someone who:

a) has lots of money
b) wants to sound just like Rod
c) is playing large rooms (300 people or more) frequently.

Excellent amps for people who do not match all of those criteria can be purchased new for $700 or less (sometimes much less).

Whatever amp you choose, a microphone will be necessary, and the Green Bullet, which runs around $90-$100 new, is the first choice, along with the Astatic JT-30, which is the mic Piazza uses, and costs about the same.

More information about the Piazza amp can be found in the Harp-L archives; there is a link to the archives at my site at http://www.hunterharp.com. I note again that many, many fine amps for harp can be bought new for less than $700. Look for an amp with all-tube preamp and amplifier stages. A VERY popular choice for harp players who want a big amp is the Fender '61 Bassman Reissue; other solid Fender amps for harp include the Blues DeVille, Deluxe Reverb, Blues Junior, and Champ, in order of decreasing power. An amp that will be used on stage should put out at least 15 watts, more if the player will be playing loud rooms or with a very large band. (Of course, a smaller amp can be miked through a PA system, and smaller amps are a LOT easier to carry. Piazza's monster weighs a ton.) The Pro Pages at my site will tell you what choices many of the top professionals have made, and I recommend a look at those pages before you decide to spend a lot of money on a boutique amplifier.

This answer was provided by harmonica virtuoso Richard Hunter.

Richard Hunter's website: http://www.hunterharp.com/

Play It Again Sam's interview with Richard Hunter: http://www.guitarsam.com/interviews/richard_hunter.htm

 

Q. I have several Hohner 270s. I am doing something wrong because after about two weeks or so they begin to have sticky notes in some of the holes. Then when I draw or blow the note is very week and then sort of pops out. This is very distracting to me. I play about three hours per day as I am trying to learn.

Now the question is how do I clean them after this happens. I have used cold water, warm water, and even water with soap in it to try to get the reads to stop sticking. But soon after I begin to play with the harp the notes begin to stick again. It does not happen until I have played a new harp for about a week or two.

A. You're not doing anything wrong. The problem you describe here results from sticky valves or "windsavers;" those are the little white plastic strips you see when you take the cover plates off, and windsaver problems are very, very common with chromatic harps. Windsavers are found covering both draw and blow reeds in the chromatic harp, but the only one that stick are the ones covering blow reeds (which, fortunately, are the visible ones, so you don't have to take the reed plates off to fix problems).

Essentially, sticking (and lots of other problems with valves) occur when your hot breath collides with (colder) outside air, which results in condensation forming on the valves. (That's why only the blow reed valves have problems; when you breathe in, there's no collision between warm and cold air, hence no condensation.)

The first thing you might try is warming your chromatic harps with a heating pad before you play them, which is something the classical virtuoso Robert Bonfiglio does before every performance.

The "popping" sound you refer to results from the two halves of the valve sticking to each other (again, because of condensation); they separate with an audible "pop" when you blow on the reed. A preventive maintenance procedure is to put a small kink in the valve, just above the point where the valve is glued to the plate. Take off the cover plates, slide an arm of a paper clip or similarly thin piece of metal under the valve (taking care not to lift it right off the plate) at a right angle to the valve. Press down to put a bend or kink in the valve. This kink will help prevent the two halves of the valve from sticking to each other. Again, you only need to do this to the valves that are showing when you remove the cover plates; DON'T remove the reed plates to work on the inside valves.

If all else fails, replace the valve (and do the procedure described above before using the instrument again). Hohner sells sets of valves fairly cheaply. Pliobond glue works well.

Valve maintenance is an ongoing issue with chromatics. On the plus side, it's easier than making reeds for an oboe or tuning a piano. Good luck.

This answer was provided by harmonica virtuoso Richard Hunter.

Richard Hunter's website: http://www.hunterharp.com/

Play It Again Sam's interview with Richard Hunter: http://www.guitarsam.com/interviews/richard_hunter.htm


Q. I have a Hohner harmonica I purchased about 6 years ago that is still extremely difficult to play cleanly. I must use a lot of pressure to draw notes and there is a lot of air leakage with the blow notes. It feels very rigid and unresponsive to play. I don't have this problem with any of my other harps, new or old. What do you recommend? Is this just a "bad" harp or is there any way to improve it's responsiveness?

A. Your message doesn't include any information on what the model is, so it's hard to be certain of the reply. However, it's very likely that the problem is a poor fit between the reed plates and the comb of the harmonica, which is most likely when the instrument has a wooden comb (such as the Marine Band) or is assembled with rivets instead of screws (e.g., older Golden Melodies and Special 20s).

Any gap, even a small one, between the reed plate and the comb will result in a very leaky instrument. In the worst case, the leakiness results from a bent reed plate (which may be so subtle as to be invisible to the naked eye), and is absolutely unrepairable short of replacing the reed plates. It is also possible that the problem is poor "gapping" of the reeds, but this usually does not involve the entire instrument.

The easiest thing to do is to return the instrument to Hohner for replacement. In the future, I recommend buying only harmonicas that are assembled using screws to hold the reedplates to the comb; these include Lee Oskars (my favorite), Hohner Special 20s, and recently manufactured Golden Melodies. With all of these instruments, you may also consider adding Micropore tape gaskets to make the instrument absolutely airtight. Instructions on fitting these gaskets to a harmonica can be found at my website at the URL below.

This answer was provided by harmonica virtuoso Richard Hunter.

Richard Hunter's website: http://www.hunterharp.com/

Play It Again Sam's interview with Richard Hunter: http://www.guitarsam.com/interviews/richard_hunter.htm


Q. Regarding harmonicas; I would like to know if there is a harmonica made with a mechanical device built in with a lever control to bend notes or some similiar design ?

A. Chromatic harmonicas use a slide lever to access the sharps and flats that do not appear on a standard diatonic harmonica.


Q. What microphone/amplifier set-up would you recommend for playing rock and blues harmonica?

A. Most harp players would probably agree that a Shure Green Bullet and a small Fender tube amp, like a Champ, or the newer Blues Jr. or Pro Jr. would be a good start for that classic sound. The Shure sells new these days for about $99.00, while the range of the amps (new) would be $275.00 or so and up, or a lot more if you were searching for an old Fender. Your amp wants to be small enough so you can turn it up to get that slightly (if not greatly) overdriven sound, but if the amp is high wattage you'll have a rough time getting the volume without lots of feedback. In a band situation, you'll most likely need to mike the amp through the PA to get your desired stage volume.


Q. I have just recently received a harmonica from my grandfather, and since it is fairly old, is there any way that I can clean or sterilize the blowing holes?

A. Cleaning a harmonica is possible, but pretty tricky, since it's all sealed, and not really made to easily come apart. (or go back together!) If it's a Hohner harmonica, you could send it to their factory, where they can clean/recondition it for you at a reasonable cost.

A quicker, but less effective method is to run warm water through it for a few seconds, and be sure to tap it out thoroughly, and leave out, holes down, on a dry cloth to drain the rest out. I have heard of people rinsing them in alcohol (the isopropyl kind) for a few seconds, and then doing the water rinse as described above.

Most importantly, get as much moisture out of it as possible when done.


Q. How do I get that "Little Walter" sound without spending a fortune?

A. The answer may be to spend less, not more. Experiment with some small guitar amps, preferably tube amps. Old Fender Champs, etc. are a good example. When the amp is loud enough to start getting some natural overdrive (not too much) work on the tone from there. Old crystal mikes would round out this ensemble, but they may be hard to find, and the good ones are usually pricey. Try any mike at first, again, maybe an inexpensive one over a better quality piece. Different combinations of mike and amp will also produce varied results. Also, Shure makes a reissue of the old "Green Bullet" mike, and you may want to try this one for obtaining a vintage sound.


Q. I saw an ad for an amplifier DESIGNED for harmonica... it was a bit pricey... but I would like to check it out again. My biggest problem is that it's so hard to compete in volume with guitar players... I'm usually fighting feedback. What would you recommend?

A. The usual way is to first search for the tone you desire, whether the amp be large or small, and regardless of output, although you will find it much easier to control your sound, and to control feedback with a smaller amplifier. Then, mike your harp amp through the PA, and you'll have plenty of ammunition against those guitar players. Just use any good vocal mike in front of your amp, and it'll broadcast your harmonica the same as the lead vocals. Let the guitars try to compete with that.

Also, some amps have a "line out" jack that allows you to run a standard instrument cable from your amp to the PA board. Same or similar result, you'll just need a $10.00 cable instead of another $100.00 mike.

As far as the harmonica amplifier you saw advertised, you should check it out. Equipment that is designed for a specific use is very likely to give you superior tone and control over your sound.


Q. What is the best key to get when buying your first harmonica?

A. The best key to start with is "C", and the reason is that 99% of the harmonica instruction book/tapes, CD's, and video tapes available are recorded in "C", and they all specify that you must use that key to be able to play along with the lessons. Some of the other most popular keys once you get out of the learning stage are "A", "D", "G", and "F".


Q. Is the harmonica an easy instrument to learn?

A. Yes. And no! The harmonica is one the easiest instruments to get some level of instant results from, and to be able to play a few songs quickly. It's also one of the most difficult instruments to master, as there are many "hidden notes" in that little thing that only a professional can squeeze out. Harmonicas are great fun to play, have been proven to provide a number of health benefits including relaxation, breathing, and can be used with just about every style of music, including classical! Check out David Harp's series of harmonica books listed in our "Music Instruction" catalog.


Q. I've been trying for months to bend notes on a harmonica. What am I missing?

A. I also had trouble getting a bend years ago, and the only it finally made sense to me was by listening to the John Sebastian six-volume cassette instruction book from Homespun.

Here's the description as best as I can relay it. Bending for beginners should be "draw" bending, in other words, sucking in, not out. Holes 4, 5, and 6 are the easiest to start with. Place your lips over hole 4 and draw the note. Now push your tongue to the roof of your mouth, leaving a narrow open channel of air from front to back, about the same as if you put a drinking straw way back in your mouth as then pushed your tongue up. Visualize your breath pointing down across the harp. This change of air-flow is what directs your breath differently through the harp and drops the note down in pitch. There's no need to change anything else, not the amount of breath, not the force of breath. Gentler is better. Just practice moving your tongue in and out of that position, and I'm pretty sure that you'll see it coming quite quickly. Then practice the other notes/holes, and you'll find that each bending note need to be treated a little differently in terms of the amount of air, which you've probably found to be true just playing straight harmonica.

The lower half of the harmonica is easier to bend than the top half, as a matter of fact, you really won't get much bending at all from the upper notes, which you need to "blow-bend". This is much like the same technique, except blowing rather than drawing. (Don't even try this at first, get the draw-bend down for now)

Things to try: Start your note with a bend, and open up to the straight-draw note.

Try draw-bend-draw-bend over and over in the same breath.

When you bend and get that sweet note, close your air-opening just a little bit more to (this may be gross, sorry) get just a bit of spit in the sound. With some practice, this'll be your "bending growl", and you can also start a note off with this sound, and then open up to your straight and clean note.

 

Email
How to Order
GuitarSam eZine
Home

Copyright © 1998, 1999, 2000 Stable Management Corporation...All Rights Reserved
Play It Again Sam....66 Main St....Montpelier VT 05602....Phone (802) 229-0295....Fax (802) 229-0755